"Play That Song Again" is the twenty-eighth Mighty Magiswords short. The short was released on MagiMobile in November 11, 2016 but was finally released online on Cartoon Network UK's YouTube channel on March 30, 2017 and, as well as the rest of the un-aired shorts, on Cartoon Network Video on May 26, 2017.
Vambre gets on Prohyas for playing the same song too much, and he exacts revenge.
- Accordion Magisword (Prohyas; 7)
- Exploding Bubble Magisword (Vambre; 6)
- Tomato Magisword (Vambre; 11)
- Golden Curls Magisword (Vambre; 1)
- Muscly Arm Magisword (Vambre; 1)
- Dolphin Magisword (Prohyas; 11)
- Sharkblade Magisword (Vambre; 2)
- Slingshot Magisword (Prohyas; 1)
- Nail Clipper Magisword (Vambre; 4)
- Dairy Product Magisword (Vambre; 1)
- Little Blue Bomb Magisword (Vambre; 2)
- Microphone Magisword (Prohyas; 2)
- Ground Pound Magisword (Vambre; 5)
- Retractable Ladder Magisword (Vambre; 2)
- A vlog based on this short was released on Cartoon Network in December 31, 2016.
- This short reveals that Prohyas gets free Slug Burgers from Witchy Simone and likes his hair turquoise.
- First time Vambre gets angry, the latter will be used on Squideo Games.