Papa Kotassian is a short, elvish creature with a purple beard, green hat and clothes.
Papa Kotassian is very goofy and upbeat but can be very vengeful and psychotic when his king was eaten.
He debuts in the short "Do You Know the Muffin King?" where he treats the Warriors to a royal banquet in Kotassium. Due to one of his villagers' head getting stuck in a tree, it took 5 hours for him to return. Upon realizing that Vambre ate their king, he tried to calmly ask if it was a misunderstanding. After understanding that Vambre truly did eat him, he and the villagers kidnap Vambre and punished her to be "noogied to an oblivion" by a stone fist. Prohyas used his lame Magiswords to create Muffin Kings for the Kotassians. Papa Kotassian stops the punishment and the villagers, including Prohyas, celebrate.
- He is based on Papa Smurf from The Smurfs.